I haven’t posted about the Supreme Court’s decision in Erica P. John Fund, Inc. v. Halliburton Co. because I viewed it as limited to a narrow issue of securities law that would not affect insurers except to the extent that they are public companies occasionally subject to defending securities class actions like any other public companies. 

Erica P. John Fund is a short unanimous opinion, authored by Chief Justice Roberts, holding that loss causation need not be proven by a plaintiff in order to obtain class certification.  The opinion is narrow in its focus and does not include any general commentary on class certification law.  It discusses Basic, Inc. v. Levinson, 485 U.S. 224 (1988), where the Court held that, for purposes of a Rule 10b-5 securities fraud claim, a plaintiff can use a “fraud on the market” theory to establish a rebuttable presumption of reliance.  The idea there is that the market price of a company’s shares reflect the publicly available information, and thus an investor can be presumed to rely on public statements about the company in buying stock at the market price.  The separate requirement of loss causation requires a showing that misrepresentations, not other intervening causes, caused the drop in the stock price.  The Court held in Erica P. John Fund that this loss causation requirement need not be proven to obtain class certification.  Most courts of appeal had taken that view, but the Fifth Circuit had required proof of loss causation. 

I don’t see this case as having a significant impact on insurance class actions outside the securities context because attempts to extend the “fraud on the market theory” beyond the securities context have been largely rejected, for example, in cases involving insurance sales practices.  Proof of loss causation is really proof of damages and not proof of one of the elements of Rule 23, as the Supreme Court concluded in a rather summary manner. 

I was surprised though by a citation to Erica P. John Fund in the Florida Supreme Court’s opinion in Sosa v. Safeway Premium Finance Company (see my blog post on the Sosa case).  In the course of discussing commonality, the Florida Supreme Court cited loss causation as an example of the type of “fact question” that did not need to be proven at class certification.  (Slip op. at 33.)  Oddly, the Florida court did not mention Wal-Mart, which focused extensively on commonality.  But that may be because the Florida opinion, issued on July 7, 2011, was largely finalized before Wal-Mart was decided in late June.  The Sosa opinion notwithstanding, I still think it is rare we will see Erica P. John Fund cited outside of the securities context, and its impact on non-securities class actions should be minimal.

Print:
EmailTweetLikeLinkedIn
Photo of Wystan Ackerman Wystan Ackerman

I am a partner at the law firm of Robinson+Cole in Hartford, Connecticut, USA.  My contact information is on the contact page of my blog.  I really enjoy receiving questions, comments, suggestions and even criticism from readers.  So please e-mail me if you…

I am a partner at the law firm of Robinson+Cole in Hartford, Connecticut, USA.  My contact information is on the contact page of my blog.  I really enjoy receiving questions, comments, suggestions and even criticism from readers.  So please e-mail me if you have something to say.  For those looking for my detailed law firm bio, click here.  If you want a more light-hearted and hopefully more interesting summary, read on:

People often ask about my unusual first name, Wystan.  It’s pronounced WISS-ten.  It’s not Winston.  There is no “n” in the middle.  It comes from my father’s favorite poet, W.H. (Wystan Hugh) Auden.  I’ve grown to like the fact that because my name is unusual people tend to remember it better, even if they don’t pronounce it right (and there is no need for anyone to use my last name because I’m always the only Wystan).

I grew up in Deep River, Connecticut, a small town on the west side of the Connecticut River in the south central part of the state.  I’ve always had strong interests in history, politics and baseball.  My heroes growing up were Abraham Lincoln and Wade Boggs (at that time the third baseman for the Boston Red Sox).  I think it was my early fascination with Lincoln that drove me to practice law.  I went to high school at The Williams School in New London, Connecticut, where I edited the school newspaper, played baseball, and was primarily responsible for the installation of a flag pole near the school entrance (it seemed like every other school had one but until my class raised the money and bought one at my urging, Williams had no flag pole).  As a high school senior, my interest in history and politics led me to score high enough on a test of those subjects to be chosen as one of Connecticut’s two delegates to the U.S. Senate Youth Program, which further solidified my interest in law and government.  One of my mentors at Williams was of the view that there were far too many lawyers and I should find something more useful to do, but if I really had to be a lawyer there was always room for one more.  I eventually decided to be that “one more.”  I went on to Bowdoin College, where I wrote for the Bowdoin Orient and majored in government, but took a lot of math classes because I found college math interesting and challenging.  I then went to Columbia Law School, where I was lucky enough to be selected as one of the minions who spent their time fastidiously cite-checking and Blue booking hundred-plus-page articles in the Columbia Law Review.  I also interned in the chambers of then-Judge Sonia Sotomayor when she was a relatively new judge on the Second Circuit, my only connection to someone who now has one-ninth of the last word on what constitutes the law of our land.  I graduated from Columbia in 2001, then worked at Skadden Arps in Boston before returning to Connecticut and joining Robinson+Cole, one of the largest Connecticut-based law firms.  At the end of 2008, I was elected a partner at Robinson+Cole.

I’ve worked on class actions since the start of my career at Skadden.  Being in the insurance capital of Hartford, we have a national insurance litigation practice and I was fortunate to have the opportunity to work on some prominent class actions arising from the 2004 hurricanes in Florida and later Hurricane Katrina, including cases involving the applicability of the flood exclusion, statutes known as valued policy laws, and various other issues.  My interest and experience in class actions gradually led me to focus on that area.

In Connecticut courts I’ve defended various kinds of class actions that go beyond insurance, including cases involving products liability, securities, financial services and consumer contracts.

My insurance class action practice usually takes me outside of Connecticut.  I’ve had the pleasure of working on cases in various federal and state courts and collaborating with great lawyers across the country.  While class actions are an increasingly large part of my practice, I don’t do exclusively class action work.  The rest of my practice involves litigating insurance coverage cases, often at the appellate level.  That also frequently takes me outside of Connecticut.  A highlight of my career thus far was working on Standard Fire Ins. Co. v. Knowles, the U.S. Supreme Court’s first Class Action Fairness Act case.  I was Counsel of Record for Standard Fire on the cert petition, and had the pleasure of working with Ted Boutrous on the merits briefing and oral argument.

I started this blog because writing is one of my favorite things to do and I enjoy following developments in class action law, writing about them and engaging in discussion with others who have an in interest in this area.  It’s a welcome break from day-to-day practice, keeps me current, broadens my network and results in some new business.

When I’m not at my desk or flying around the country trying to save insurance companies from the plaintiffs’ bar, or attending a conference on class actions or insurance litigation (for more on those, see the Seminars/Programs page of this blog), I often can be found playing or reading with my young daughter, helping my wife with her real estate and mortgage businesses, reading a book about history or politics, or watching the Boston Red Sox (I managed to find bleacher seats for Game 2 of the 2004 World Series when Curt Schilling pitched with the bloody sock).  When the weather is good I also love to take the ferry to Block Island, Rhode Island and ride a bike or walk the trails there. If you go, I highly recommend the Clay Head Trail.